"News about the USAP, the Ice, and the People"
United States Antarctic Program United States Antarctic Program Logo National Science Foundation Logo
Robotic sub on ship.
Photo Courtesy: Peter Milne
The robotic sub is about to be deployed into Pine Island Bay and sent underneath the ice shelf. The sub discovered a high seafloor ridge where the ice shelf once sat. With the ice now floating above the ridge, more warmer water is getting underneath the ice shelf and causing it to thin.

Rapid retreat

Discovery of seafloor ridge by robotic sub offers insight into ice loss in Antarctica

A robotic submarine, making a rare foray underneath an ice shelf, found an important clue as to why one of West Antarctica’s key glaciers is draining more ice toward the sea in recent years.

Scientists already knew that a small ice shelf that fronts Pine Island Glacier in the Amundsen Sea had been thinning for some time. The ice shelf acts as a sort of cork in the wine bottle, preventing the glacier from draining straight into the ocean. But as that “cork” weakens, the ice flows faster, eventually contributing to sea-level rise.

An international team of researchers reported this week in the journal Nature Geoscience why that “cork” has loosened so much in recent years: They found a 300-meter-high ridge on the seafloor where the ice shelf was once attached.

The retreat of that grounding line — where ice and land meet — since the 1970s toward the continent has allowed relatively warm ocean water to flow over the ridge and into a widening cavity that now extends to an area of 1,000 square kilometers under the ice shelf. The warm water — known as circumpolar deep water (CDW) — is causing the bottom of the ice shelf to melt, resulting in continuous thinning and acceleration of the glacier.

The authors said that based on early satellite imagery, the glacier was last in contact with the highest point of the ridge in the early 1970s, when imagery showed a bump in the ice surface that disappeared several years later.

“The discovery of the ridge has raised new questions about whether the current loss of ice from Pine Island Glacier is caused by recent climate change or is a continuation of a longer-term process that began when the glacier disconnected from the ridge,” said Adrian Jenkins External Non-U.S. government site, a scientist with the British Antarctic Survey (BAS) External Non-U.S. government site and lead author of the paper, in a press release.

Pine Island Bay
Photo Credit: Jo Johnson/BAS
Ice fills Pine Island Bay.
Robotic sub in the water.
Photo Courtesy: British Antarctic Survey
The BAS autosub in the water.

While atmospheric temperatures in West Antarctica are on the rise around the northern end the Antarctic Peninsula, that wouldn’t explain the thinning of the Pine Island ice shelf. Instead, the culprit is the CDW, which is a few degrees centigrade warmer than the melting point of the ice.

The warm water itself is likely a natural phenomenon. However, in recent years, there’s building evidence that suggests changes in atmospheric circulation are pulling more of the CDW onto the Amundsen Sea continental shelf, into its deep, glacially carved troughs and underneath ice shelves, which has accelerated melting.

It’s less clear whether these changes in circulation are natural or human-induced. Recent research suggests that increasing temperature differences between the stratosphere and troposphere have increased westerly winds around the continent. In some regions, those winds may pull more of the warmer, deeper water onto the continental shelf and the ice margin.

The reason scientists believe atmospheric changes may be linked to human causes is two-fold. First, the ozone hole has cooled the stratosphere, the layer of the atmosphere above the troposphere that people inhabit. Second, the strong greenhouse effect caused by the anthropogenic input of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere has warmed the troposphere.

The results published the Nature Geoscience paper come from data collected during a 2009 research cruise aboard the U.S. Antarctic Program’s Nathaniel B. Palmer External U.S. government site, led by chief scientist Stan Jacobs External Non-U.S. government site, a co-author on the paper.

BAS deployed a robotic sub off the Palmer a half-dozen times, operating it 167 hours, with more than half that time spent underneath the ice shelf. The authors note that the information collected by the sub is unique, accounting for 90 percent of all the data ever collected from automated underwater vehicle (AUV) deployments beneath ice shelves. [See related article: Pine Island cruise.]

Jacobs noted that in recent years estimates of Antarctica’s contributions to sea-level rise have changed “from near-zero to significant and increasing.” In fact, the authors note that West Antarctica now accounts for about 10 percent of global sea-level rise.

Yellow robot sub and ice shelf in distance.
Photo Courtesy: BAS
The autosub prior to deployment to the Pine Island ice shelf.

“Now, finding that [Pine Island Glacier’s] grounding line has recently retreated more than 30 kilometers from a shallow ridge into deeper water, where it is pursued by a warming ocean, only adds to our concern that this region is indeed what glaciologist Terry Hughes called the ‘weak underbelly’ of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet,” said Jacobs, a senior research scientist at Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory at Columbia University External Non-U.S. government site.

The finding was quickly making headlines around the world and setting ripples through the polar research community. The results of the study are already affecting a future project planned at the Pine Island Glacier region, where scientists will drill through the floating ice shelf from the surface to deploy instruments into the ocean cavity to learn more about what is happening between the ice and water interface.

“It radically affects our thinking about where to drill and place our ocean profilers, and we are in close communication with the BAS folks about this,” said Robert Bindschadler External U.S. government site, chief scientist of the Hydrospheric and Biospheric Sciences Laboratory at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center External U.S. government site

Bindschadler is the principal investigator (PI) on the Pine Island Glacier Ice Shelf expedition External U.S. government site, a National Science Foundation External U.S. government site-project that will begin in 2011-12 after construction of a deep-field science camp this upcoming summer season in Antarctica. [See previous articles: Dress rehearsal and Pine Island Glacier.] 

“The retreat of PIG is episodic,” said Bindschadler, who was not involved in the robotic submarine work. “Each ungrounding episode leads to a phase of rapid retreat. We’ve been through one. Continued attack on the ice shelf by warm water will lead to another and another.”

NSF-funded research in this story: Stan Jacobs, Adrian Jenkins and Hartmut Hellmer, Columbia University, Award No. 0632282 External U.S. government site. Pine Island Glacier Ice Shelf: Robert Bindschadler and Roberto Behar, NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, Award No. 0732906 External U.S. government site; Tim Stanton, Naval Postgraduate School, Award No. 0732926 External U.S. government site; David Holland, New York University, Award No. 0732869 External U.S. government site; Sridhar Anandakrishnan, Penn State University, Award No. 0732844 External U.S. government site; Miles McPhee, McPhee Research Company, Award No. 0732804 External U.S. government site; and Martin Truffer, University of Alaska, Fairbanks, Award No. 0732730 External U.S. government site. 

back to top