Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

Research diver Rory Welsh prepares to return to the surface through a dive hole after collecting specimens from the seafloor. Walsh and principal investigator Andrew Thurber are studying the food web dynamics of marine organisms, including worms and bacteria that live in the seafloor.

Feast or famine

Research divers study the table manners of small marine organisms

By Peter Rejcek, Antarctic Sun Editor

Posted November 30, 2012

Exploring the deep ocean requires expensive research vessels and complex instruments to retrieve samples from the seafloor — not to mention the trauma of yanking a marine organism up 4,000 meters from the bottom of the ocean. So why travel down so far when you can do the same sort of research at a mere 20 meters in the sub-freezing waters of Antarctica?

That’s what brought scientists Andrew Thurber and Rory Welsh to McMurdo Station back in August to learn how benthic communities of bacteria, marine worms and other tiny marine organisms function on a feast or famine diet. Understanding those dynamics will also lead to more details about how much carbon remains locked deep in the ocean — an important measurement in the calculus of climate change.

It’s mostly famine for the animals on the seafloor, except for the occasional pulse of food that comes when phytoplankton (microscopic marine plants) bloom in the surface waters in the summer months and then die, falling to the ocean bottom like scattered breadcrumbs.

Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

Spiophanes tcherniai live in tubes. They stick out their palps, those red fleshy projections, to catch food or pick it up off of the seafloor.

Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

View of a particularly "wormy" core from the seafloor.

“This big input of food and then no input of food is pretty much what the rest of the planet sees,” said Thurber, a postdoctoral researcher in the College of Earth, Ocean, and Atmospheric Sciences at Oregon State University . “It’s the same kind of situation here.”

One of the chief goals of the National Science Foundation -funded project is to study how life subsists on such a meager food supply with so many tiny mouths to feed. In particular, the scientists are interested in a prolific marine worm (Spiophanes tcherniai) found in tremendous numbers in McMurdo Sound, from 150,000 to 180,000 animals per square meter in the seafloor. That’s more than ten times what’s found in the open ocean.

“The number of animals on the seafloor [in McMurdo Sound] is the highest on the planet,” Thurber noted.

The marine biologist is also interested in how bacteria are involved in the seafloor food cycle. There is evidence that when food is plentiful, the bacteria actually compete at a disadvantage with the worms and other organisms in the seafloor sediments.

But during the many months when food is scarce, research suggests the bacteria turn generous, entering into a symbiotic relationship with the more complex organisms and helping them consume the less readily digestible organic compounds still available. Thurber likens the process to how bacteria help cows digest the fiber that makes up grass and hay.

“As soon as the food runs out, they turn into this facilitating capacity, allowing the community to persist,” Thurber explained from McMurdo Station where he and OSU graduate student Welsh were wrapping up the first half of their field season in Antarctica.

The pair arrived at McMurdo Station in August when winter darkness still prevails. The timing was deliberate to mimic the lightless conditions that exist in the deep ocean. It’s also a period when little or no food is available to the benthic communities. In other words, the researchers wanted to collect specimens and conduct experiments when the sea critters were most famished.

But they found something unexpected on their many dives through the sea ice into the freezing waters: Food was available in the form of benthic diatoms, a major group of algae that makes up phytoplankton blooms in the light-filled euphotic zone of the ocean, but also grows on the seafloor.

Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

An experiment left on the seafloor to determine photosyntheric activity among the benthic community.

Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

Sea stars and sea urchins are among the organisms found in abundance on the seafloor of McMurdo Sound.

Photo Credit: Andrew Thurber

Scientist Rory Welsh carries sediment core samples back to the surface in a plastic milk container.

Such biological growth had been nearly absent a decade ago when Thurber was last at McMurdo Station and icebergs had blocked McMurdo Sound, causing the sea ice to thicken and affecting the biological rhythms below. However, in the last couple of years, normalcy has returned, with the sea ice blowing out of the region at the end of each summer season.

“This year there’s actually a ton [of benthic diatoms],” Thurber said. “We’ve seen an incredible bloom, so we’ve been able to measure the amount of in situ production and compare that to that phytoplankton bloom that’s coming in.

“It’s not what we were expecting to do, but it’s become a crucial part of the project,” he added.

One of the main experiments based on this discovery involves Thurber and Welsh, both cold-(really cold)-water divers, collecting small cores of sediment from the seafloor. One tube has been blacked out with electrical tape, which prevents photosynthesis by diatoms. The other small core of ocean mud is clear. They leave the experiment alone in the water for 24 hours.

The scientists then measure the amount of oxygen in each microcosm. The clear core will contain more oxygen from photosynthesis, so that by subtracting the oxygen measurement from the blackened tube, they can determine how much photosynthetic energy is being produced.

Their calculations should eventually reveal the amount of food that is produced right at the seafloor, as well as additional details about the carbon cycle. The animals and bacteria also play a role in what scientists call “carbon sequestration,” and determine whether the carbon consumed is buried for geologic time or released back into the ocean and the atmosphere on much shorter timescales.

Back in the lab at McMurdo Station, the researchers work on experiments with specimens that provide data on how the seasonal pulse of food from phytoplankton blooms change the dynamics of the food web. There are three scenarios: no food, a reduced regime of about 70 percent based on the conditions caused by the icebergs a few years ago, and the business-as-usual conditions.

A similar series of experiments run concurrently but all the bacteria are removed in those scenarios. Thurber said it turns out that antibiotics work exceedingly well against the polar bacteria, which haven’t built up a resistance like other microbes where antibiotics have been heavily employed.

Thurber said it would be a year before full results from the project are available, as much work remains to be done back at his university lab. But the macrofauna in both series of experiments — with and without the bacteria — appear to operate at similar levels.

“That suggests the bacteria may not be competing very well with the animals because the macrofauna are [reacting at the same level] regardless of the amount of food added. That was a surprising result,” he explained.

Expect more surprises to come. Thurber will briefly leave McMurdo Station this month but return later in the season to collect additional specimens after the phytoplankton blooms at the height of the summer. Follow their research at Cold Dark Benthos 

NSF-funded research in this story: Andrew Thurber, Oregon State University, Award No. 1103428 .